← The Journal
Decision 2 of 5

Rent or buy?

The monthly maths often favours renting; the case for buying rests on how long you stay and how prices move. Start with the one number that frames it, then see the city-by-city grid.

The numbers to start with

From Rent or buy? Start with one number: what rent is as a share of the price. Each figure is sourced or marked as an illustration there.

  • 2.7% to 3.8%
    Median gross rent as a share of asking price a year, across the five Atlas cities
  • 2.5×
    Year-one loan interest on a Gurgaon median flat, compared with the year's rent
    Illustration
  • 12 years
    Years until buying overtakes renting for a Gurgaon median flat, if prices rise 7% a year and the renter earns 8%
    Illustration

Read in this order

  1. Recommended first read

    Rent or buy? Start with one number: what rent is as a share of the price

    A flat with a median asking price of ₹1.43 crore in Gurgaon rents for about ₹31,900 a month, roughly 2.7% of the price a year. A 9% loan on three-quarters of it costs about 2.5 times that in interest alone in year one.

    Buyer Guide · 3 min readRead this first →
  2. Rent or buy? In five Indian cities, it comes down to one race: house prices against your investments

    We ran a rent-vs-buy model on real asking prices and rents in Gurgaon, Noida, Bengaluru, Hyderabad and Mumbai. With rents at roughly 3% of prices, buying only wins if home prices grow about as fast as your investments would. Here's the grid, city by city.

    Market Analysis · 4 min read
  3. The Bengaluru couple on Reddit can afford their ₹2.7 crore flat. The price is the real question.

    A Bengaluru couple asked Reddit whether to take a ₹1.8 crore loan for a ₹2.7 crore J P Nagar flat. On their reported finances the EMI is comfortable. But at ₹15,000 per sq ft, the price sits above three-quarters of asking prices in that pincode. Here's the full working.

    Buyer Guide · 4 min read
Next decision
How much can I afford?
Continue →

The other decisions

By city

Have a property in mind?

See how its asking price and your finances fit together. Start with a free snapshot.

Get my free snapshot →